Mets Advised to Apply “Pressure” on Pete Alonso After He Rejects $90M Offer by Signing Another Boras Client

Tired of the ongoing Pete Alonso-New York Mets drama? It’s far from over. No matter what the Mets offer, Alonso continues to reject it. The team has been pursuing him since his 2023 season, but no deal has been reached, as their offers don’t meet the $200 million threshold set by Alonso and his agent, Scott Boras. With many first basemen already off the market, third baseman Alex Bregman has emerged as a potential target for the Mets. But are they ready to make the necessary internal adjustments?

Watch What’s Trending Now!

The Mets are aiming to build a super team this season, featuring star shortstop Francisco Lindor and the potential signing of Juan Soto. With Alonso’s impressive consistency (hitting 7.12% of home runs throughout his career), keeping him would clearly benefit the team. Additionally, his status as a homegrown Mets player adds an emotional element to the situation. However, since Alonso became a free agent in early November, negotiations have been ongoing. After rejecting a 7-year, $158 million extension from the Mets, he recently turned down another offer: a 3-year deal worth $90 million, complete with an opt-out clause. But is this all driven by his agent, Boras?

Recent rejections seem influenced by Boras, though Alonso’s 2023 season didn’t show the same issues. Alonso initially wanted to test the free-agent market, but that decision hasn’t paid off so far. Meanwhile, the Mets hold a significant card in Alex Bregman. After prolonged negotiations between Boras and the Houston Astros, the team grew frustrated and signed Christian Walker to a 3-year deal, which made Bregman available. His acquisition would provide a substantial defensive upgrade.

Rumors are just that, but if Pete in fact turned down 7/$158 ($22.5 mil AAV) thru his age 36 season, hired Boras, had a down year, then turned down 3/$90 ($30 mil AAV) after his market disappeared, you may have to *PIVOT* to put even more pressure on him.

I wouldn’t close the… https://t.co/hhi6nDCDIL

— John Saponaro (@johnsaponaro) December 27, 2024

With a league-leading 242 assists, 103 putouts, and a .972 fielding percentage, bringing in this Gold Glove Award winner would likely require Mark Vientos to move to first base. This potential shift could pressure Alonso to make a quicker decision. Imagine if the Mets signed both players—Alonso, an elite home run hitter with 226 homers, and Bregman, who has hit 191 career homers. Such a lineup would undoubtedly form a super team. However, the logistics of fitting both into the team raises a significant question: could this backfire?

Should Pete Alonso reconsider his strategy?

Rumors suggest that Alonso’s concerns go beyond money; he also seeks security. The reported $30 million AAV for 3 years didn’t seem worth it, and he could’ve accepted the Mets’ 7-year extension offer. With spring training still ahead, Alonso’s market hasn’t risen as expected, and lowering his demands might bring in teams like the Chicago Cubs or Washington Nationals. If the $90 million rumor holds true, Alonso, a homegrown star, may feel slighted.

This would open the door for the Mets to sign Alex Bregman, with the only other competition being the Red Sox, who would also need to adjust their lineup. But does this mean Alonso’s time with the Mets is over? It’s possible. Remember Aaron Judge? He turned down a $400 million contract from the San Diego Padres and re-signed with the New York Yankees for $360 million over 9 years. If the Mets are willing to increase Alonso’s contract length and Alonso is willing to lower his asking price, a middle ground might still be reached. This could allow Alonso to retire with the team he started with.

According to Baseball Hut, Alonso may not reach the $200 million mark. They reference Michael Conforto’s rejection of a Mets offer ($100 million for 5 years) and how it contributed to the team’s failure to reach the postseason in 2022 and the NL Championship Series in 2023. Additionally, right-handed hitters typically don’t command as high a market value, so Alonso may need to adjust his expectations.

In one way or another, the Mets are likely to sign one of Boras’ clients, but it’s unlikely they will sign both. As a power hitter, Alonso may have to retire before hitting 40, at which point the Mets could revamp their lineup. But before that happens, should they settle terms with Alonso? Let us know your thoughts in the comments.